“Cutting out carbs can contribute to weight loss initially. However, eliminating whole food groups, such as grains, milk, yogurt, and fruit, is likely unsustainable and inadequate in nutrients,” Popeck cautions. “Fiber will certainly be lacking, as well as calcium, potassium, and other vitamins and minerals.”
Popeck also notes that it’s unclear whether this diet may work in the long run. “I believe low-carb diets may be nutritionally unbalanced and difficult to maintain,” she says. “I work with many patients in my clinic who have tried the Atkins diet and successfully lost weight, but then [they] regain the lost weight and in turn have a difficult time losing weight again.”
Instead, she says, she encourages her clients to try to think of diet planning more as a lifestyle — one in which all foods can fit.